Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Columbia County, FL & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Columbia County, FL

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
Nationwide A+ 8.2%
Erie A+ 7.02%
State Farm A 6.9%
Allstate A+ 4.9%
Liberty Mutual A 3.2%

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in Columbia County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Denise Sanders Lutcf 116 N Walnut St
32091
(904) 964-7707
Chadwick L Hartsfield 1120 NW 13th St
32601-4136
352-372-8406
Jim Moran 1201 NW 13TH ST
32601
800-891-4222

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in Columbia County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Frank James Ehrman Jr 677 Sw Bascom Norris Dr Ste 10
32025
(386) 755-1666
William Viviano 1515 County Rd 210 W Ste 103 Jacksonsville
32259
Dale Kenneth Jackson Agency 234 SW Main Boulevard
32056-3658
386-755-2399
Paddock Insurance Agency Ltd 2400 NW 6TH ST
32609
(352) 373-2003
Donnie R Kays Insurance Inc. 4056 W Newberry Rd
32607
(352) 335-2505

Top Erie Home Insurance Agents in Columbia County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Brunner Insurance Inc. 14793 Us 301
32091
904-966-0011
Paciotti Insurance Agency Inc 622 SW MAIN BLVD
32025
386-752-8660

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Columbia County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Jim Miskovich 2811 NW 41ST ST
www.jimmiskovich.com 32614
352-377-2002
Jim Moore 200 WHITE AVE SE
www.jimmooreinsurance.com 32060
386-362-2110
Jim Neal Clu, Chfc 986 N TEMPLE AVE
32091
904-964-7826
Patty Edwards 1720 OHIO AVE N
32064
(386) 364-1000
Derek Alota 16 SW 2nd Ave
www.alotainsurance.com 32601
(352) 373-0333
Jim Moreland 313 OHIO AVE N
www.jimmoreland.com 32064
386-364-2886
Jim Million 4880 W NEWBERRY RD STE 100
www.jimmillioninsurance.com 32607
352-378-2511
Jim Minifie 2770 NW 43RD ST STE C
www.jimminifie.com 32606
352-367-1050
Dan Normoyle 140 NW 75th Drive Suite A
www.dannormoyle.com 32607-1587
352-332-6881
Jim Molina 3501 A W UNIVERSITY AVE SUITE A
www.jimmolinainsurance.com 32607
352-371-7977

Top Allstate Home Insurance Agents in Columbia County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Michael Quataert 2811 Nw 41 St Gainesville
32606
(352) 559-8291
Gary C. Weaver 630 NE Santa Fe Boulevard
32643
(386) 454-1642
Christopher Petty Ste C12 9542 Argyle Forest Blvd
32222-2824
904-854-4700
Dan O'Donnell 904 SW SR 247 Branford Hwy
32025-1592
386-752-7521
Gary Grivner 2361 Blanding Blvd
32068
(904) 282-7665
Edward O. Reyna 2640 Blanding Blvd Ste 206
32068
(904) 406-7838
Wetzel Valley Ins 955 Sw Baya Ave
32025
Steven Saul 3225 Nw 13Th St Gainesville
32609
Michelle Lee 43 Knight Boxx Rd Ste 2
32065
(904) 213-9518
Alsop & Associates Insurance Agency 2622 NW 43rd St Ste A2
32606-6678
352-395-7552

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Columbia County, FL

State FarmNationwideAllstate
Median Home Value ($) 101,250111,250111,250
Construction year 201320141983
Home Coverage ($) $100000-$125000$125000-$150000$150000-$175000
Total Premium ($) $1982$1682$2547

Columbia County, FL Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Liberty Mutual upto 15%
Nationwide upto 11%
Erie upto 19%
Allstate upto 21%